Evaluating Claims
Grade 6 · English Language Arts · Reading Informational Text · Idaho, USA
Lesson Summary
Not all claims are equally valid. Evaluate claims by checking whether they are supported by sufficient, relevant, and credible evidence.
Explanation
A claim is a statement that someone believes to be true. To evaluate a claim, ask three questions: Is the evidence sufficient (is there enough of it)? Is it relevant (does it actually relate to the claim)? Is it credible (does it come from a trustworthy source)? Claims supported by facts, data, and expert opinions are stronger than those based on personal stories or opinions alone. Being able to evaluate claims helps you become a critical thinker who does not accept everything at face value.
Practice Questions
Q1: A website claims a new drink cures colds, but the only evidence is one person's story. Is this strong evidence?
Answer: No, one person's experience is not sufficient or scientifically credible evidence to support a medical claim.
Q2: What makes a source credible?
Answer: A credible source is written by experts, published by a trustworthy organization, and backed by verifiable facts or research.
Q3: An article claims video games improve problem-solving skills. It cites a study from a major university. Is this better evidence than a friend's opinion?
Answer: Yes, a university study is more credible and relevant than a personal opinion because it uses scientific methods.
People Also Ask
What is Evaluating Claims in Grade 6 English Language Arts?+
Evaluating Claims is a lesson in the Reading Informational Text chapter of Grade 6 English Language Arts. It is part of the Idaho, USA school curriculum and covers key concepts that students need to understand at this level.
What grade level covers Evaluating Claims?+
Evaluating Claims is taught in Grade 6 as part of the English Language Arts curriculum in Idaho, USA.
How can I help my child with Reading Informational Text in English Language Arts?+
Start with the lesson summary and explanation on this page. Practice the questions provided, then use TutorTom for personalized, step-by-step help with Reading Informational Text topics.